Brent sits down with Danny Kirk, founder of ReddiReach, to unpack the rapidly shifting world of AI search optimization. The conversation zeroes in on how brands can position themselves to be mentioned when consumers ask ChatGPT, Claude, or other chatbots about products in their space. From Reddit marketing tactics to schema optimization, Danny shares practical guidance for merchants trying to stay visible as search behavior transforms. Along the way, he and Brent, both endurance runners, touch on the parallels between building a marketing snowball and training for the long haul.
Key Takeaways
- Reddit is a goldmine for LLM training data. Passionate communities organized into subreddits provide the human-generated, constantly updated content that AI models crave.
- Be human on Reddit. Automation can destroy your reputation quickly. Use tools to identify opportunities, but write comments yourself.
- Fix your website first. Schema markup and LLM-readable content are foundational before any off-site strategy makes sense.
- Feed AI accurate information. Chatbots may already carry incorrect assumptions about your brand, so correcting the record is part of the job.
- Start now, not later. AI-driven traffic may be small today, but the compounding effect makes early action essential.
- Local businesses need a different playbook. Google reviews, local subreddits, and local SEO fundamentals still carry weight.
- Watch for in-chat purchasing. One-click buying inside ChatGPT could change how customers reach (or bypass) your website entirely.
About Danny Kirk
Danny Kirk is the founder of ReddiReach, an agency focused on getting client brands mentioned in AI search results through Reddit marketing and broader AI search optimization. Interestingly, Danny didn’t come from a traditional marketing background. He studied music in college before stumbling into the startup world roughly 15 years ago, where he experienced a mix of failures and significant wins. He launched his agency about a decade ago, starting in email marketing, expanding into search, and eventually building a specialty around Reddit and AI-driven discovery. As a longtime Reddit user himself, he was able to spot the platform’s growing influence on LLM training well before it became mainstream conversation.
Episode Summary
Danny kicks things off by explaining what ReddiReach actually does: helping clients earn brand mentions inside AI search results. He walks through why Reddit sits at the center of this strategy, noting that LLMs are literally buying Reddit’s data because subreddits organize themselves around passionate topic communities, generating fresh human conversation daily. Unlike walled platforms, Reddit is openly accessible, which made it the easy first stop for scrapers and now for formal partnerships with OpenAI and Google.
Brent asks whether companies like Amazon are making a mistake by blocking LLM bots, Danny suggests it probably is a mistake since the data will be sourced elsewhere anyway. He’d rather see brands negotiate partnerships than shut the door entirely.
Danny outlines how a specialty running store could start showing up in AI conversations. First, search your brand name plus “Reddit” to see if you’re already being discussed. If so, join the conversation transparently as the founder. If not, find your tribe, understand their problems, and contribute value-add content without being salesy.
On automation, Danny is firm. “Reputation takes a lifetime to build and a second to destroy.” He notes that Reddit has strong incentives to keep bots off the platform and is actively cracking down on automations. Tools like SubReddit Signals can help identify opportunities, but the writing itself should stay 100% human.
They shift to how LLMs filter noise from Reddit’s firehose. Danny points out that upvotes and downvotes give AI natural signal weighting, letting humans essentially rank the quality of the content for the machines. He also raises an important point: AI may already have incorrect information about your brand, so part of AI search optimization is feeding accurate context to correct misperceptions.
Reddit’s dominance in citations has also shifted. Back in September of last year, Reddit accounted for roughly 80% of all citations, which Danny calls absurd. That number now sits closer to 20%, and he expects it to settle in the single digits as data sources diversify. That’s why ReddiReach now offers full AI search optimization covering Reddit marketing, digital brand mentions, PR, backlinks, AI-friendly content formats, and website optimizations.
For merchants worried about declining click-through rates as Google summarizes answers directly, Danny recommends four pillars: optimize your site’s schema so LLMs can read it, engage with Reddit strategically, publish content AI loves (product roundups, comparisons), and use intel tools like AIPeekaboo or Profound to track how you rank against competitors.
Local businesses get a slightly different prescription. Danny highlights a running store near him in Salida, Colorado, and notes that local players should focus on Google reviews, local subreddits, and traditional local SEO fundamentals.
Looking ahead, Danny is watching two developments closely: in-app one-click buying through ChatGPT and the arrival of ads inside AI chat experiences. Both could reshape ecommerce dramatically. He also cautions that AI has its own incentives. He shares a story about Lovable pushing him toward custom builds instead of out-of-the-box solutions because, as he puts it, “it’s selling me tokens.”
Brent and Danny close with a shared observation: the generation younger than them will grow up never knowing “ten blue links.” They’ll only know AI chatbots. That’s why building your presence now, even when AI traffic sits in single digits, matters so much.
Final Thoughts
Danny Kirk’s message is straightforward. Brands that want to stay visible in the AI era need to start planting seeds today, whether that means schema optimization, thoughtful Reddit engagement, or diversified content strategies. The snowball may be small right now, but momentum compounds. So here’s the question worth chewing on: when your customers stop scrolling and start chatting, will your brand be part of the conversation, or will you be reading between the lines wishing you’d shown up sooner?
Connect with Danny on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/danielpkirk/
This has been produced in cooperation with Content Cucumber
https://www.contentcucumber.com/
Follow Talk Commerce on your favorite platform:
Website: https://talk-commerce.com/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@talkcommerce
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/talkcommerce.bsky.social
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/talk-commerce/id1561204656
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7Alx6N7ERrPEXIBb41FZ1n
Twitter: @talkingcommerce
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/talk-commerce
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/talkingcommerce
