When I sat down with Will Haire, co-founder of BellaVix, I knew we were in for a masterclass on marketplace strategy. With over half a billion dollars in sales under his belt across Amazon, Walmart, and Target, Will brought the kind of real-world experience that cuts through the noise of generic e-commerce advice.
The Prime Day Phenomenon: More Than Just Another Sale
Will’s perspective on Prime Day immediately caught my attention. As he explained, “Prime Day is a tent pole sales event for Amazon sellers” – one of only two times per year when products hit their lowest prices. But here’s what I found particularly insightful: the strategic timing matters more than most sellers realize.
The psychology behind Prime Day shoppers fascinated me. According to Will, these aren’t gift buyers – they’re shopping for themselves. Beauty products, supplements, and household items dominate because people are treating themselves to deals. This self-purchasing behavior creates a different dynamic than holiday shopping seasons.
What struck me most was Will’s advice about the post-Prime Day period. Those “FOMO shoppers” who arrive late to the party represent an untapped opportunity. As someone who’s watched countless merchants miss this window, I appreciate Will’s emphasis on maintaining momentum with scaled-back promotions rather than going dark immediately after the main event.
The Learning Curve: From Google Ads Veteran to Amazon Expert
Will’s background as a “recovered Google ads manager” resonates with my own observations about the advertising landscape. His comparison of Amazon today to Google’s early days sparked a fascinating discussion about platform maturity and opportunity.
The key difference Will highlighted – that advertising spend influences organic ranking on Amazon – represents a fundamental shift in how we think about paid media. On Google, your ad spend doesn’t boost your organic search rankings. On Amazon, it’s all interconnected. This creates what Will calls a “really fun place to be” because your advertising investment has compound effects.
I’ve seen this firsthand with merchants who treat Amazon advertising like traditional PPC. They miss the broader ecosystem play where ad spend builds audiences, improves rankings, and creates long-term visibility benefits beyond immediate ROAS.
Marketplace Reality Check: Amazon, Walmart, and Target
Will’s candid assessment of the marketplace hierarchy offered some hard truths. While Amazon dominates with roughly 50% of e-commerce, Walmart presents a more complex picture. His insight that Walmart prioritizes buy-online-pickup-in-store for e-commerce users explains why third-party sellers often struggle there.
The “10-20% of Amazon volume” expectation for Walmart third-party sellers provides realistic benchmarking. But Will’s long-term perspective on Walmart’s infrastructure advantage – “there’s a Walmart within 10 miles of every major city” – suggests patience might pay off for sellers willing to play the long game.
Target’s invitation-only model creates what Will describes as a better user experience through limited competition. Having worked with merchants frustrated by Amazon’s overwhelming choice paralysis, I see the appeal of Target’s curated approach, even if it limits advertising sophistication.
The Brick-and-Mortar Connection
Will’s discussion of the 80% offline transaction statistic opened my eyes to an often-overlooked perspective. His story about a supplement brand executive explaining shelf space impressions was particularly illuminating – one Target store generates 10,000 daily impressions that can’t be directly tracked but create massive brand awareness.
This physical-digital connection represents something many pure e-commerce players miss. The instant validation of seeing a product in Target, then finding it on Amazon, creates a trust factor that pure digital brands struggle to achieve. It’s why some brands view marketplace success as a stepping stone to retail partnerships rather than an end goal.
Platform Mastery Over Diversification
Perhaps Will’s most actionable advice centered on platform mastery. His philosophy – focus on one platform until you achieve predictable, scalable results – challenges the “everywhere at once” mentality I see from many merchants.
The logic is compelling: spreading efforts across multiple platforms often results in mediocre performance everywhere rather than excellence anywhere. Will’s emphasis on getting to seven figures through focused execution before expanding aligns with successful scaling patterns I’ve observed across industries.
The Future of Marketplace Advertising
Looking ahead, Will’s acknowledgment that AI might replace advertising managers “in the next three to six months” sparked an interesting conversation about automation’s role in marketplace management. While he said it jokingly, the underlying point about rapidly evolving tools and capabilities is real.
The sophistication of Amazon’s advertising platform continues to grow, with new features for targeting cart abandoners and building custom audiences. Will’s insight that brands succeeding at scale understand marketplace sales as just “part of the journey” while building their brand elsewhere reflects a mature understanding of omnichannel commerce.
Final Thoughts
My conversation with Will Haire reinforced that successful marketplace selling requires both tactical execution and strategic thinking. Prime Day isn’t just about discounting products – it’s about building audiences, generating data, and creating momentum for long-term growth.
For merchants looking to scale on Amazon and beyond, Will’s approach offers a refreshing combination of realistic expectations and actionable strategies. Whether you’re preparing for the next Prime Day or building your first marketplace presence, focusing on platform mastery while understanding the broader ecosystem will serve you better than chasing every new opportunity.
Want to dive deeper into Will’s marketplace insights? Listen to our full conversation on Talk Commerce, and don’t forget to check out Will’s newsletter on LinkedIn for ongoing e-commerce intelligence that cuts through the noise.
Listen to more conversations about marketing strategy here
